Milk Punch – Classic 1862 Recipe

This post may contain Amazon affiliate links and as an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. See our affiliate policy for more info.
Milk Punch Cocktail
Milk Punch Cocktail

Using Dairy In Cocktails.

So you may notice this is a milk punch, but the milk punch does not use milk. Mixing with dairy is a pain in the ass, and that’s because alcohol, like acid, causes milk protein to bind together and make cheese. What protects the protein from binding together is fat. Regular milk doesn’t have enough fat, so you will make curds and whey punch every time instead. The trick is to balance the higher ABVs with the correct fat percentage. This one comes in around 15%, and at that abv half & half works well. Something like a white Russian, which is 30%, needs heavy cream because that’s too much booze and would curdle half & half. If you use milk, you would need to add less alcohol and water it down some to hopefully not have it curdle.

On a side note, I experimented with making this with oat milk and almond milk, and it was ok. They tasted fine, but they lacked the creaminess of actual dairy. Kind of like substituting almond milk in coffee. It’s OK but not good. Also, this follows older recipes pretty closely, but I feel this is a superior version. One of the oldest ones I could find was Jerry Thomas’s version.

• 15mls/ tea spoon of sugar
• 60mls/ 2 ounces of brandy
• 30mls/ 1 ounce rum
• remainder of glass filled with milk and ice

I like booze, but it was too boozy and the milk curdled. I took the ingredients of most of the milk punches I found, increased the fat content, and decreased the booze by a 1/4, and that’s what this recipe is. It won’t curdle, and I think the parts are a better balance.

What Is The Difference Between Eggnog And Milk Punch

Eggnog and milk punch are similar drinks, but the main difference is eggnog is made with both dairy and eggs, and milk punch is only made with dairy. Adding an egg or not also changes how the drink is consumed. A milk punch is shaken and served right away with the intent that it is consumed right then and there. On the other hand, eggnog is typically stored and consumed over a more extended period. Eggs add a thicker texture to the drink, adding stability. Egg yolks are around 10 to 15% lecithin, a powerful emulsifier. Lecithin emulsifies fat, preventing it from binding together and forcing them to remain evenly suspended in a liquid. Egg yolks are also 20% fat and add around 4 to 5 grams of fat each. Fat will stabilize proteins and prevent them from denaturing in a highly alcoholic or acidic environment. What does this all mean? It means the milk in eggnog will not clump together and get cheesy. Eggnog can be prepared and placed in the fridge to develop flavors further. Days and even weeks later, it will still look the same. The same can not be said for a milk punch. Milk punch will start to curdle after a few minutes. So it’s a trade-off. Milk punch is thinner and not so heavy, but it must be consumed immediately. Eggnog is a richer, thicker drink, but it has a long shelf life.

Recipe Resources


Download The Official Vintage American Cocktails App

Discover what classic cocktails you can make right now with the ingredients you have. Check out the Vintage American Cocktail app.

Milk Punch

0 from 0 votes Only logged in users can rate recipes
Course: DrinksCuisine: American






Total time



Learn how to make a classic Milk Punch.


  • 3 dashes Vanilla Extract

  • 1/2 oz Simple Syrup

  • 2 oz Cream

  • 1 oz Gold Rum

  • 2 oz Brandy


  • Combine all ingredients in the shaker and add crushed ice to the shaker.
  • Lightly shake the drink.
  • Pour the whole contents of the shaker into the glass.



Make Cocktails Like A Pro

If you have ever struggled with a recipe or wonder why yours are not turning out like they do at the bar then check out my simple step-by-step videos. I will walk you through how to expertly build each drink so you get consistently great results.

  • Free and simple step by step videos.
  • Tips and tricks from years of experience.
  • Historically accurate and balanced recipes.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *